Republican mocked women for abortions then ran ad with wife's story

By Gary D. Robertson

Aug. 3, 2024 4:41 PM PT

RALEIGH, N.C. — North Carolina Republican gubernatorial nominee Mark Robinson has been battered for months by his Democratic rival and other adversaries for seeking additional abortion restrictions beyond current state law and for past comments upbraiding women on the issue.

“Abortion in this country is not about protecting the lives of mothers. It’s about killing the child because you weren’t responsible enough to keep your skirt down,” Robinson said in a Facebook video in 2019, the year before he was elected lieutenant governor. Democratic nominee Josh Stein, the current attorney general and an abortion rights supporter, has shown the video in ads since June.

Robinson’s campaign said this year that he supported an abortion ban after roughly six weeks of pregnancy, with some exceptions. Many women don’t know they are pregnant at six weeks. Previously, Robinson left the impression that he’d support something even more severe, saying in 2020, for example, that “for me, there is no compromise on abortion.”

Now Robinson started airing a new commercial Friday that describes his wife’s abortion decades ago and leaves the impression he’s comfortable with the state’s 12-week ban on most abortions.

For Robinson, it would be a significant policy shift.

For decades, the GOP campaigned on restricting abortion throughout the country. But as abortion rights have driven turnout for Democrats and appeared as a vulnerability for Republicans, Robinson’s approach reflects ongoing efforts by conservative politicians to appear more moderate on abortion rights or avoid the topic on the campaign trail — or otherwise risk losing at the ballot box in a post-Roe vs. Wade world.

The stakes are high in North Carolina, where races for statewide office are usually close affairs and the winner of this closely watched gubernatorial campaign in November could have much to say about whether the Republican-controlled General Assembly will be able to advance its conservative agenda without resistance.

The campaign ad on television and on digital platforms shows Robinson and his wife, Yolanda Hill, holding hands. They discussed her abortion publicly in a 2022 video, but the potential audience now is much greater.

“Thirty years ago, my wife and I made a very difficult decision. We had an abortion,” Robinson says in the ad, adding that it was like a “silent pain between us that we never spoke of.”

Hill added: “It’s something that stays with me forever.”

“That’s why I stand by our current law,” Robinson goes on to say, pointing to what he calls “commonsense exceptions” for pregnancies resulting from incest and rape and when the life of the woman is in danger.

Asked whether Robinson was altering his views on abortion, campaign spokesperson Mike Lonergan said Friday that “the Legislature has already spoken on this issue.”

In May 2023, the Republican-controlled General Assembly enacted legislation — overriding Democratic Gov. Roy Cooper’s veto — that changed the state’s ban on most abortions from after 20 weeks of pregnancy to 12 weeks.

If elected governor, Robinson “will work to make North Carolina a destination for life by building a culture that does more to support women and families, including bolstering adoption, as well as foster and child care,” Lonergan said.

Stein’s campaign said later Friday that the Robinson ad was the “latest example of him running away from his extreme and toxic stance on abortion.” Stein’s team has alleged that Robinson would seek an abortion ban with no exceptions if elected.

“If North Carolinians want to know where Mark Robinson really stands on abortion, they should listen to every other comment he’s made on the issue before today,” Stein campaign spokesperson Morgan Hopkins said.

Former President Trump, though boasting about appointing the Supreme Court justices that allowed for the overturning of Roe, has at times sought a more cautious stance on abortion rights this election. He has dodged questions and leaned on his go-to response that the Supreme Court decision merely returned the abortion issue to the states.

Broad support for abortion rights among voters nationally has been credited for preventing an anticipated “red wave” in 2022 and delivering wins for Democrats in Kentucky’s gubernatorial race and in the Virginia state Legislature after Republican Gov. Glenn Youngkin failed to rally voters behind a proposal to ban abortions after 15 weeks with exceptions.

Cooper, the North Carolina governor, was barred by term limits from seeking a third consecutive term but handed the Democratic baton to Stein, a former state senator who worked under the now-governor when Cooper was state attorney general.

Hopkins said in June that Stein “supports the Roe v. Wade framework of the past 50 years that protects women’s reproductive freedoms and restricts abortion later in pregnancy unless a woman’s life or health is at risk.”

Such a framework generally allows for abortions in most cases through the point of viability, which is usually between 24 and 26 weeks of pregnancy.

Robertson writes for the Associated Press. AP writer Christine Fernando in Chicago contributed to this report.