A champion to some, a threat to others, the judge leading Beirut blast probe presses on
BEIRUT — For eight months, he has quietly investigated one of the world’s worst non-nuclear explosions with only four assistants — and a lot of powerful detractors trying to block him.
In that time, Judge Tarek Bitar has become a household name in Lebanon and a staple of every news bulletin.
For many Lebanese, Bitar’s investigation of last year’s massive Beirut port explosion is their only hope for truth and accountability in a country that craves both. Billboards in Beirut showing a fist holding a gavel read: “Only Tarek can take our revenge,” a play on Arabic words using the judge’s last name.
But to the country’s entrenched political class, the enigmatic 47-year-old has turned into a nightmare. Politicians have united — which they rarely do in Lebanon — to remove him from his post, apparently deeming him a threat much greater than the country’s collapsing economy, the state’s empty coffers and burgeoning unemployment, poverty and public anger.
Bitar has not shied away from summoning a dozen senior former and current government officials, some of them on charges of criminal negligence and homicide with probable intent. He issued arrest warrants for two former ministers when they refused to appear before him.
More than 215 people died in the Aug. 4, 2020, explosion, which was caused by the detonation of hundreds of tons of ammonium nitrate stored in a warehouse for years, apparently with the knowledge of senior politicians and security officials who did nothing about it. The explosion also injured 6,000 people and destroyed parts of the city.
The family of a Lebanese man who was critically injured in last year’s massive explosion at Beirut’s port say he has died, nearly 14 months after the blast.
More than a year after the government launched a judicial investigation, nearly everything else remains unknown, from who ordered the shipment to why officials ignored repeated warnings of the danger that the storage posed.
But the low-profile Bitar — there are only a few public pictures of him — has earned the trust of many Lebanese, including relatives of the victims.
“We have big faith, up to 90%, that Judge Bitar will lead us to justice,” said George Bezdjian, whose daughter Jessica, a nurse, was killed in the explosion.
Bezdjian and others who have met Bitar describe him as a soft-spoken, calm and courageous man who has stayed clear of political affiliations or nepotism and displayed professionalism and doggedness.
The so-called Pandora Papers show how Lebanon’s politicians and bankers stowed wealth in offshore tax havens and used it to buy expensive properties.
On a recent day there was no electricity in the judge’s office. In the humid room, Bitar and two assistants shared one computer monitor, a legal expert familiar with the case said.
“It is quite shocking when you walk into his office and there is one computer screen and two people helping him ... as he is trying to solve the biggest crime in Lebanon’s modern history,” the legal expert said, speaking on condition of anonymity to divulge details from the private meeting.
The second judge to lead the case, Bitar was appointed in February. His work has been challenged every step of the way.
At first, suspected officials took cover behind parliamentary or professional immunity, declining to appear before him. They accused him of singling out some officials and not others, in an apparent attempt to stoke sectarian grudges in a country divided along sectarian lines. Then they sued him and tried to discredit him, alleging that he showed bias and was allied with foreign powers.
News Alerts
Get breaking news, investigations, analysis and more signature journalism from the Los Angeles Times in your inbox.
You may occasionally receive promotional content from the Los Angeles Times.
Earlier this month, the call to remove him finally came — from Hezbollah leader Hassan Nasrallah, arguably the country’s most powerful man.
An anti-Bitar protest by supporters of Hezbollah and the allied Shiite group Amal, led by Parliament Speaker Nabih Berri, escalated into the worst violence the capital has seen in years. Seven people were killed, and accusations followed that Bitar was a threat to social peace.
“The investigative judge Bitar has become a real problem in Lebanon,” Hezbollah deputy leader Naim Kassim said Saturday. “Because of him we nearly had major strife,” he said, in the clearest attempt yet to tie Bitar to civil unrest.
Hatem Madi, a veteran judge and prosecutor, said he had never before witnessed such a standoff between the political class and the judiciary.
The imposing grain silos at Beirut’s port mostly withstood last year’s massive explosion — but now serve as reminders of negligence and destruction.
The new government of Prime Minister Najib Mikati is already in a deadlock over how to respond to calls for removal of Bitar.
Meanwhile, Bitar has not backed down, re-issuing his summonses to senior officials. He now moves around with guards.
The judge has been open to visitors and questions about the legal process, but he is careful not to divulge his next moves, the legal expert said.
Born in 1974 to a secular Roman Catholic family from northern Lebanon, Bitar studied law at Lebanese University in Beirut and later trained at a judicial academy to graduate as a judge. He was appointed a public attorney in northern Lebanon in 2012, a post he retained until 2017, when he was appointed head of the Beirut Criminal Court.
More than 200 people were killed, not because of an attack but because the government failed to deal with dangerous chemicals.
There, he issued several sentences in cases that shook Lebanon, such as the shooting at close range of a young man following a traffic accident. He also fined private hospital doctors a hefty sum for a case of malpractice that cost a young girl her four limbs.
Bitar was first approached by the former justice minister to investigate the port explosion soon after the blast. Realizing the size of the challenge, Bitar told people he met that he asked for a bigger team of assistants for the probe. He also requested that the immunity of lawmakers be lifted so he could question them.
No one replied to his requests, which would have required legal amendments, the legal expert said.
The same minister approached Bitar again in February after his predecessor was removed by a court order following legal challenges from politicians. He agreed after realizing he was the only candidate.
Relatives of victims of the port blast describe Bitar as deeply sympathetic to their quest for justice. One man said the judge told him that he approached the case as if his own daughter had been killed.
Bezdjian said Bitar told the families that he felt a responsibility because of those killed, wounded and displaced and because “half of my capital was destroyed.”
Sign up for Essential California
The most important California stories and recommendations in your inbox every morning.
You may occasionally receive promotional content from the Los Angeles Times.
