The Iowa caucuses rarely pick the president. Here’s why they still matter
Iowa voters aren’t going to pick the country’s next president. But they will eliminate several possibilities.
The rap on the state, which begins the balloting with its Feb. 3 caucuses, is that it is too small and rural to speak for the rest of America.
However, the state's impact is undeniable.
In the last seven contested races for the Democratic nomination, five candidates went on to become the Democratic nominee after winning Iowa. Three winners of the New Hampshire primary, which traditionally follows soon after, went on to claim the nomination.
That is because the main function of the early states is to cull the field of hopefuls, separating the also-rans from candidates with a real shot at success.
No two campaigns are alike. But the past could provide some clues to what happens next.
Twenty-seven Democrats have had their names in the 2020 mix at one point or another. That is a record and more than the last four contested campaigns combined.
Most have already quit the race. Many more will make the choice after voters in Iowa and New Hampshire weigh in.
The closest examples to this election may be the 1984, 2004 and 2008 contests. Each was competitive with large – or so it seemed at the time – fields of eight candidates apiece.
Iowa trimmed the field each time. New Hampshire eliminated even more of those running. But the true reckoning came on so-called Super Tuesday, the coast-to-coast balloting extravaganza that takes place this year on March 3. (California will vote then along with 14 other states.)
Candidate dropouts during nomination process
1984
1988
1992
2000
2004
2008
2016
Iowa
New
Hampshire
3 dropouts
Super
Tuesday
Convention
Candidate dropouts during nomination process
1992
2000
2004
2008
2016
1984
1988
Iowa
New
Hampshire
3 dropouts
Super
Tuesday
Convention
Candidate dropouts
during nomination process
New
Hampshire
Super
Tuesday
Convention
Iowa
1984
3 dropouts
1988
1992
2000
2004
2008
2016
The five Iowa winners who went on to become the party’s nominee were: Walter Mondale, Al Gore, John F. Kerry, Barack Obama, Hillary Clinton. Only one of them – Obama in 2008 – went on to win the presidency.
The New Hampshire victors who claimed the nomination were Michael Dukakis in 1988, Gore in 2000 and Kerry in 2004. None of them reached the White House. Each lost to a Republican named Bush.
How past Iowa winners fared
Walter
Mondale
Richard
Gephardt
Tom
Harkin
Al
Gore
John
Kerry
Barack
Obama
Hillary
Clinton
1984
1988
1992
2000
2004
2008
2016
Named
nominee
Won
presidency
How past Iowa winners fared
Named
nominee
Won
presidency
Hillary Clinton
2016
Barack Obama
2008
John Kerry
2004
Al Gore
2000
Tom Harkin
1992
Richard Gephardt
1988
Walter Mondale
1984
How past Iowa winners fared
Named
nominee
Won
presidency
Hillary Clinton
2016
Barack Obama
2008
John Kerry
2004
Al Gore
2000
Tom Harkin
1992
Richard Gephardt
1988
Walter Mondale
1984
The candidate who stands out is Bill Clinton, who was elected president in 1992 after failing to win Iowa or New Hampshire.
He defied history under a distinct set of circumstances. The '92 field included Iowa Sen. Tom Harkin, which effectively rendered the caucuses moot, and Sen. Paul Tsongas of Massachusetts, whose victory in New Hampshire was discounted because of his next-door neighbor status.
Clinton's second-place finish was good enough to stick around, picking delegates prior to Super Tuesday.
Then the Arkansas native benefited from what amounted to a Southern primary, He won Florida, Louisiana, Mississippi, Missouri, Oklahoma and Texas on Super Tuesday.
Clinton called himself the "Comeback Kid" and he took the Democratic nomination and, ultimately, the White House.