NBC’s ‘Peter Pan Live!’ raises stakes with flashier set, bolder cast

Reporting from BETHPAGE, N.Y. —  In a soundstage on a particularly desolate patch of Long Island, Allison Williams is dangling in the dark from a 25-foot harness. The “Girls” star floats stealthily above a brightly lighted bedroom where a make-believe family belts out the “Peter Pan” song “Tender Shepherd.”

Then, just as the children finish singing and a quiet settles on the room, the bedroom windows swing open and Williams swings and swoops into the scene, landing cat-like on the floor.

“Everyone here is working toward the same goals,” Williams says a moment later, slipping off the harness and zipping up a winter coat. “It’s just that our enemy is physics.”

NBC will also try to defy a few Newtonian laws when its cameras capture “Peter Pan Live!” from these studios Thursday night. A follow-up to last year’s massively viewed, critically dissed “The Sound of Music Live!,” the network’s new live-theater go-round, mostly in British accents, seeks to replicate 2013’s populist success while upping the stakes.

“Peter Pan Live!” is a far more elaborate production, with flashier set pieces and effects than the Von Trapp tale. It also features a bolder cast — in addition to Williams in the title role, Minnie Driver as the narrator and grown-up Wendy, and theater performers Christian Borle, Taylor Louderman and Kelli O’Hara in supporting parts, Christopher Walken stars as Capt. Hook. It’s his first major network appearance in more than a decade, and the sight of an icon from “The Deer Hunter” playing a singing-and-dancing pirate has the improbable effect of making a flying Marnie only the second-most unlikely image in the new production.

The idea behind the show, producers say, is to combine old and new to unique effect. As a live TV event, the production is a throwback to another era, yet it aims to capitalize on the real-time immediacy of the social media age (and outmaneuver a few DVRs besides).

And as much as the piece’s message about the appeal and perils of eternal youth taps into a modern zeitgeist, NBC is tackling the show differently than other contemporary iterations. “Peter Pan Live!” has none of the postmodern twists of the recent Broadway hit “Peter and the Starcatcher” or the upcoming Hugh Jackman origin-tale film “Pan.” Instead, it looks to tell the story as it hasn’t been told in decades — straightforwardly.

“We think there is a large audience for traditional family entertainment done with some new bells and whistles,” says executive producer Neil Meron, who with fellow exec producer Craig Zadan is the current producer of the Academy Awards; the two were also behind “Sound of Music Live!” “We want to create something that multiple generations can gather to watch together.”

Since the 1954 stage version launched with Mary Martin, “Peter Pan” has had many runs, including on television.

NBC aired what was essentially the original Broadway version in 1955, then mounted a new production and broadcast it in 1960; that latter edition was then polished and re-aired multiple times over the decades that followed. Various revivals have also popped up on Broadway, most famously with Sandy Duncan as Peter in 1979. In recent years, new film and stage versions began taking a flip-it-on-its-ear, “Wicked”-like approach to the material.

“Peter Pan” has remained popular thanks to its compelling, slightly melancholy boy who never grew up. Peter (usually played by a female due to the lilting melodies) begins the show visiting the house of the Darling children, including big sis Wendy, and taking them all back to Neverland. There he and his Lost Boys do battle with Capt. Hook, the man who blames Peter for the loss of his hand and vows revenge on the eternal child.

The new production follows the story line and music of the original, though it adds some curlicues, including three new songs based on melodies from other musicals. Producers enlisted Amanda Green, whose father, Adolph, was a lyricist on the 1954 version, to put new lyrics to the melodies. The results are numbers titled “Vengeance,” “Only Pretend” and “A Wonderful World Without Peter.” (A fourth song, “When I Went Home,” is revived from road productions of the original “Peter Pan.”)

As they rehearse “Vengeance,” Walken leads a large entourage of villainous lackeys in a kind of two-step across the deck of a pirate ship. “A hook for every boy and a boy on every hook,” he sings as he pledges bloody justice. Walken is in full get-up — pointy beard, oversized robe and the signature hook, of which he says, “We’re still working on so it’s not too dangerous.”

Despite the heightened nature of the spectacle, there is something understated — skeptics might call it aloof — about Walken’s performance. His might be the most scrutinized turn of the production. Williams is a fresh-faced talent with a singing background, and many of the others are Broadway veterans. But a man known for his off-kilter edginess has mostly been a song-and-dance man just for laughs on “Saturday Night Live,” and his soft-shoeing blackbeard is the show’s chanciest move. “(He’s a villain but he’s also a sweetie,” says Walken of his interpretation of the role. “Hook really just wants to be loved.”)

There is also much sidekick gusto from Borle, the “Sound of Music” and “Peter and the Starcatcher” veteran who does double duty here as Hook consigliere Smee and the Darling father. “This is just a little more elaborate than ‘Sound of Music,’” the actor says dryly of the scope of the production shortly after rehearsing a number in an entirely different section of the soundstage.

Indeed, where last year’s telecast was a traditional three-wall affair with basic blocking and Carrie Underwood singing, “Peter Pan Live!” is a colorful, swinging spectacle with multiple giant sets, smoke machines, fake night skies and a purple-hued Neverland created by the Broadway set-designing stalwart Derek McLane. The show aims to be the ultimate cinema-stage hybrid, which can create challenges — McLane says he initially wanted even more vibrant colors for Neverland, but they overwhelmed when viewed on a screen.

“There were a lot of voices that wanted to put this on like a traditional stage show,” Zadan says. “But this is a fantasy, so we wanted it to feel like that.”

To handle the moving parts, the production has hired two directors, the Emmy-winning award-show veteran Glenn Weiss and the Tony-winning Broadway choreographer Rob Ashford. During rehearsals, Weiss stood behind the monitors as he watched nearly a dozen simultaneous angles, calling out numbers the broadcast will switch to with the split-second timing of a conductor. Unlike a straight stage show — which plays out all the action at once and lets theatergoers decide where to train their eyes--even small misalignments in camera-cutting here means the viewer will be looking at the wrong thing.

Weiss and his team stopped every few minutes to huddle with Williams and others and work out various kinks. “It’s not like football or most live broadcasts where you just cover the event,” Weiss says. “You really have to create it as you go.”

This has added up to some pretty large stakes. NBC on Thursday has one chance to make it right; a second take for a flubbed scene isn’t an option.

And while “Peter Pan Live!’s’” budget hasn’t been disclosed, there’s a reason (besides the DVR-proofing) that the network has been seeking a reported $350,000-per-30-second spot — this is not a low-budget enterprise. The aerials are being orchestrated by Flying by Foy, the Las Vegas giant that builds such an apparatus for massive stage productions (including “Peter Pan”) that tend to run for years, not one night.

“It’s a big bet and a big expenditure and hopefully a big payoff,” says Robert Greenblatt, chairman of NBC Entertainment.

Greenblatt says the network would break even with numbers “significantly below” the average 18.5 million viewers who tuned in for “Sound of Music.” And there are intangible branding benefits to “Peter Pan Live!” no matter where the ratings end up, he adds, since the production complements the network’s big-ticket events such as the Olympics and the Golden Globes.

“Sound of Music” was mostly panned and provided cultural blood sport for both professional critics and social-media live-snarkers. If the pattern is repeated, “Peter Pan Live!” could solidify a new type of commercial-entertainment genre: the massively popular, broadly derided live-event broadcast. As Greenblatt quips of last year’s telecast, “Everyone hated it but our audience.”

And there’s money to be made even with negative reactions — rubberneckers, after all, count toward viewership figures too.

Teasers for “Peter Pan Live!” have already engendered some Twitter titters. Chatting with the cast and crew, one finds them at the ready with some persuasive explanations: earnestness invites snark; it’s no fun for social media users to compliment live events so everything is skewed to the negative.

Performing in a show like “Peter Pan Live!,” they say, simply means that these reactions come with the territory.

“I get it. We’re the musical-theater kids, and everyone likes to make fun of the musical-theater kids,” Williams says. “But I’d ask that people turn off their snark machines. Not permanently and not even for a long time. Just for a few hours.” Then she stands up, floats above the set and begins another song.

------------------------

‘Peter Pan Live!’

Where: NBC

When: 8 p.m. Thursday

Rating: TV-G (suitable for all ages)